First,
we must understand that polling percentages under Indian
conditions are deceptive. Lok Satta's surveys reveal that
voter registration is extremely flawed. In urban areas in
AP, about 26% of the names in electoral rolls are of ineligible,
dead or fictitious persons, and need to be deleted. In Hyderabad
city this percentage of wrongful inclusion is 22.3%. therefore
any polling percentage should be calculated on a smaller
base excluding ineligible votes. Among the eligible votes
registered, the actual polling percentage is about 66%,
which is not bad at all. That still leaves us with two problems.
About 34% of those eligible and registered to vote have
not voted. And there are some 16% or more eligible persons
living in the city who are not enrolled as voters. Lok Satta
mounted a campaign with MCH during November 16 - 30 to include
and delete names in voter lists. The Election Commissions
(EC) at state and national levels were very proactive but
the citizens' response is luke warm, with only about 40,000
additions and deletions - probably 10% or less of what needs
to be done! The EC has partially agreed at Lok Satta's insistence
to make the post office a nodal agency for voter registration,
and make the process accessible. Under these circumstances,
reduced polling percentage may actually mean declining false
voting!
Second,
many voters are repelled by the political process and inadequate
choice of candidates. Parties have become private fiefdoms,
and decent people increasingly shun politics. Muscle power,
distribution of money and liquor, lack-lustre and irrelevant
campaigns put off many people. We should make political
process more attractive, honest and people-friendly. Internal
democracy in parties, choice of candidates through some
form of primary elections, and interactive and civilized
methods of campaigning like TV debates are needed to enthuse
voters.
Third,
many among the middle and upper classes have not internalized
the notion of democracy - equality of human dignity and
principle of one-person, one-vote. There are many who stay
away from the polls for fear of having to rub shoulders
with their domestic servants! Unless we all recognize the
dignity of labour, and respect each individual regardless
of birth and occupation, we cannot build a democratic or
peaceful society. We should realize that our security and
well being lie in the prosperity and dignity of all. As
Lincoln put it succinctly, a nation divided against itself
will fall.
Fourth,
there is growing cynicism about the outcome of elections.
Many people feel that no matter who wins the election, we,
the people, end up losing! While the poor still vote to
express their anger, or show their relevance at least for
one day, or because they get paid for the votes, the middle
and upper classes shun polls. But it is dangerous to ignore
politics and elections. As Plato said, "the punishment
suffered by the wise who refuse to take part in the government,
is to live under the government of bad men." The only
antidote to the ills of a democracy is more and better democracy.
By staying away, we are only ensuring the victory of crooks
and fools and perpetuating a vicious cycle.
Finally
urban people fail to recognise the importance of local governments.
The businessman, the bureaucrat and the academic feel comfortable
dealing with a centralized government extending patronage
to cities. There is aversion to local politics. We fail
to realize that all governance is about people, and all
politics is local. In villages, people understand the value
of local governments, and take greater interest. We need
to recognize that the city government matters. Rudolph Guiliani
made a spectacular difference to New York city as a Mayor.
His leadership, skill and commitment revived a city on the
brink of collapse. The key to success is that he had the
power to make a difference. With local governments emasculated,
we fail to give them importance. We need to genuinely empower
the city government and establish the links between our
vote and public good; our taxes and public services; and
authority and accountability. Only then will people be enthused.
Now
that election is over, we need to take city governance seriously.
Ward committees in each locality with share of taxes and
control over staff will make all the difference between
decay and rejuvenation. Citizen's Charters compelling timely
response and compensation for delay will work miracles in
delivery of services. Local justice through speedy procedures,
right to information, and a strong and independent ombudsman
are ways to bring life back to the city and make citizen
the centre of our political process. We need to stand up
and fight for these. If we don't care, no body will. Certainly
the rapacious politician and corrupt bureaucrat will not
care to improve things. Let us begin with our locality and
city, and the country will take care of itself.
***